Catholic Exchange Forums » Faith and Life

intellegence vs widsom

(55 posts)

1 2
fishman - Member

I think I know how to start at least:

"fear of God is the begining of wisdom"

Posted 1 year ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

inelegance - and at first I thought you were just not a very good speller

 How does one overcome the tendency to rely to heavily on the intellect?  prayer, ask for what you do not have and patience - holding one's tongue { not very good at it myself }

Most importantly how does one grow in true wisdom? And true humility.    I think again the answer is prayer. Knock and He will open...

I believe it was St Francis of Assissi who said, "preach the Gospel always and use words when necessary."

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 1 year ago #
lpioch - Moderator

Just want to add here (hope to have time later to expound further) that I very much resonate with your question!  Thanks for asking.  I will look forward to answers and to bringing out of myself some insights that maybe I have not defined better before.

Keys:

Prayer.  Those who rely more on intellect than on wisdom have a pitiful prayerlife.  You cannot gain wisdom without prayer and a personal relationship with the 3 persons of the Trinity.  You can gain intellect whenever and however.  Wisdom is a gift.  It must be given.  It cannot be taken.  You must insistantly ask for it.

Be childlike.  (not childish!)  This, of course, relates to prayer.  But the more humble and simple we are with God, the more we gain in wisdom.  Thank God he hides truths from the "wise" and gives it to the childlike.  Having children really teaches me a LOT about my relationship with God!

Seek spiritual direction.  If your soul is not being directed by a good guide, you will most likely never see with the eyes of another...only your own.  A very limited vision.  In spiritual direction, the grace is there for the eyes of the "other" to be that of God's.  If left to our own devices, we can convince (rationalize) ourselves of anything.

 

I'm sure there's much much more to be said.  Must get the kids to bed and call all the new parents at the school tonight!  I can't wait to read responses.

Posted 1 year ago #
royal osiodhachain - Inactive

Dear Ipioch, The answer I would recommend is to allow your intellect to lead you to wisdom. Intellect is merely the workings of your brain. If you use your brain as you do any other part of your body for which it was intended, you will allow your brain to reflexively search for wisdom. Remember God created your brain as well as your heart. The way intellect is exercised in religion is through what the Pope defined as faith and reason. We have faith in what God has told us and we strive to have a reason for everything we do. Reason is where the intellect can help decipher what is reasonable. In humility, reasonable behavior is humble, so you need your intellect to reject what is not humble. Your heart will long for wisdom and love. Love is the greatest goal of wisdom and so reasonably, intellect cannot love, only your heart can love and Christ said, "Faith, hope and love abide, and the greatest of these is love"  And so in conclusion, love is wisdom. As Saint Paul says, "Love lifts us up above the law" and as Christ said, "Love covers a multitude of sin". Fear of punishment is not the same as love.

Intellect is simply put your memory and your search. If you know the answer then you draw it from your memory and if you do not know the answer, then you search with your intellect and allow your heart to tell your intellect what is the correct answer according to reason and faith.

Prayer is for calling the Holy Spirit to gain understanding which is not the same as intellect. Intellect can process and store in memory the understanding which comes from the Holy Spirit yet it is the heart that embraces understanding with love. 

In the Holy Love of God I am your brother in Christ and my name is Royal

Posted 1 year ago #
Tarheel - Member

Ah fishman I see we have something in common.  For years I really thought I knew the Catechism and the Bible.  I even astounded people with how quick I could reference a passage in the Bible or direct someone to a section in the catechism.  Then I decided to teach CCD.

Boy did I learn how lacking I was in knowledge and understanding.  I struggled for the first year of teaching.  At the end of the year I went to my DRE Sister Julia Marie (A wonderful person) and told how I had struggled teaching and felt inadequate even though I was very adept and knowledgeable of the Holy Scriptures and catechism.  I remember like it was yesterday.  Sister Julia smiled and said "Any fool can recite the Scriptures and quote from our catechism, but it takes feeling and love to understand them."  She told me to go home and pray for understanding and wisdom.

 And it has been through prayer that I have been fortunate to understand more about the Holy Scriptures and our catechism.  And through this process I feel I have gained a little wisdom.  I feel that wisdom and life experiences go hand-in-hand.  And Sister Julia was right in that any one can read the Bible, quote from it, refer to it easily, and even memorize long passages.  But knowledge and understanding takes a different and sometimes more difficult path.

 

Intellect can help us know something but wisdom allows us to understand it and learn from it.

 

I agree with lpioch.  Prayer is key.  Praying to our Heavenly Father as a child talks to his father.  Remember we aren't on the same level as God.  He is our Father.

 

Spiritual direction requires a good guide.  Choosing this guide takes a little wisdom and understanding which is obtainable through prayer.

 

I know that prayer has helped me become a better teacher, father , and husband.  It enabled me to seek understanding not just knowledge.  But it also did something else for me.  For some reason I cannot quote from the scriptures as I used too.  But I find comfort in what I read.  (One day I hope to get a better understanding of what St Paul writes.  His teachings take some serious additional study before I can get a "handle" on them.)  Being able to refer to sections in the catechism is difficult now.  But, I find myself reading the catechism and spending more time on a single section to get a better understanding and I refer to my Compendium and other study aides.

 

I haven't spoken to Sister Julia since Hurricane Katrina but our priest here is a wonderful man with a unique way in explaining things and reminding me that our main spiritual guide is Jesus Christ.

 

Thanks for starting this forum.  Hope it keeps going.

 

tarheel

 

 

Posted 1 year ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

The fear of the LORD is the beginning of knowledge,
       but fools despise wisdom and discipline. Proverbs 1:7

I was for a long time afraid of God and the punishment I deserve. It took a long time to understand that first I need to love God and because of this love I will fear offending Him. I am a work in prgress.

Today's youth exhibit this lack of fear in regards to any authority whether it be parental, academic or civil. They lack discipline and sacrifice.

I offer that we need fasting in conjunction with prayer. One needs to be disciplined to be open to discipline. I am often astonished at the amount of time Jesus spent in prayer. I am still trying to learn that lesson. Where was Jesus before the temple story and before He started His public ministry? Why, He was fasting and praying;wouldn't you with such an undertaking in front of you? Or would we...?

When Joseph and Mary had done everything required by the Law of the Lord, they returned to Galilee to their own town of Nazareth. And the child grew and became strong; he was filled with wisdom, and the grace of God was upon him.

 Then he went down to Nazareth with them and was obedient to them. But his mother treasured all these things in her heart. And Jesus grew in wisdom and stature, and in favor with God and men. Lk 2:39-40,51-52

After reading these verses there is other things to be pondered: His parents did everything required, Jesus was obedient{disciplined}...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 1 year ago #
fishman - Member
more then one poster here has recently reminded me of a struggle within my own life.  Which of coarse I would like to see some discussion on ( or I would not have posted the question here;)

I am someone who was born with and taught to culture within myself a high degree of intelligence.  Somewhat later in life I came to the startling ( to me at least) realization that intelligence and wisdom are in no way related virtues and that in fact intelegance is not properly a virtue at all.  It is a gift which can be used for both good and evil as it’s possessor wills.

 So here in lies my questions.  How does one overcome the tendency to rely to heavily on the intellect?  How does one distinguish true wisdom from mere good argument? Most importantly how does one grow in true wisdom? And true humility.   
Posted 1 year ago #
fishman - Member

Thanks for the good comments everyone !!

 

Gk - i think the soul also has a capacity and necessity for emotion and or affectivity.  Think about happiness, love, devotion etc .. are 'feelings' so it seems necessary the soul be able to have a type of feeling. 

 

David - thanks for the spelling correction.  As it happens the two topics ( poor spelling and intelligence) are actual interrelated.  Most people who have dyslexia also have above 200 IQ's.

 

Royal - I do not think the intellect can bring a person to wisdom , not in and of itself.  The reason being is that intelligence is the ability to store , retrieve and analyze data.  Wisdom is the ability and desire to comprehend the meaning of events and live rightly in reality.

 

An intelligent person can know what they are doing is wrong and be unwise enough to do it anyway.  Satan is a million times more intelligent then anyone in this forum , but he has not a drop of wisdom because wisdom is a virtue , of which the devils have none.

  

lpioch - I know what you mean about children.  My wife and I have been recently blessed with our first child.  So much to learn :)

 

childlikeness is an expression of absolute trust.

 

Tarheel - thanks for your words. Prayer is key ... because wisdom is a virtue and virtue is a gift from God.  Also, I thin wisdom must be learned by experience so contact with the source of all wisdom would seem essential to become more wise.  I agree being able to quote something does not equate to understanding it.  Satan himself demonstrates he can and does quote scripture. 

  My wife once told me something very wise: ‘do you think you can come to know God through you mind?  God is infinite and your mind is finite.  The closest you can come to knowing God is to know him in your heart’.
Posted 1 year ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

inelegance - if not a spelling error, than a Freudian slip???

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 1 year ago #

What a great discussion. 

I have recently been listening to Babsie Bleasdell and her lecture called Refurbishing the Soul available on EWTN.  She reminds us that the soul is made up of 3 things: our understanding, our memory and our will.  Therefore the soul is not our spirit but three real attributes that guide us through life.  Our soul is our being, our reality and it is this soul that we live close to or far from God with.

I have realized that understanding is not equal to intelligence.  It has more to do with wisdom or the lack there of.  Memory is not intelligence either.  And our will barely has anything to do with intelligence.

fishman,

I, like you, fail miserably in guiding myself to a right relationship with God and the world.  So with you I ask: where and how can we grow in wisdom and humility?  Do our souls go where souls are called to go?  Not via pride and intelligence alone ...

GK - God is good!

Posted 1 year ago #
AlvinaL - Inactive

Thanks for the many good responses.  A recent CE article stated that humility is the foundation for all the virtues.  It’s important to develop a personal relationship with God and prayer leads the way to God.  I found it necessary to:

1. Make the decision to pray daily.

2 Choose a time of day and a space in your home to pray.

3. Select prayer materials.

            Bible reading for the day or the Psalms for reflection

            Prayer book(s)  (daily Novena to the Holy Spirit is my choice.)

            Picture of Jesus or crucifix placed at eye level for reflection

4. Journal for recording daily reflections related to your prayers.

Have a wonderfully blessed day.

Posted 1 year ago #
fishman - Member

some nice thoughts there.

detrich von hildebrand claims humility is the highest of all human virtues.

He calls it a human virtue because it is one we can work for ... as opposed to a divine virtue ( such as love ) , which it is impossible to progress in without grace.  Humility is the pre-disposition to recieving grace.

 

Posted 1 year ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

Lord, give me the wisdom of Samuel to listen more than I speak and to take time to reflect on You.

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 1 year ago #
royal osiodhachain - Inactive
Dear fishman, You wrote: you do not think the intellect can bring a person to wisdom. 

In your case only  you are correct because you do not think. 

However, you are incorrect in anyone else's case because the prayer before the reading of the gospel said by the priest is, "Oh Lord, open my heart and mind to accept your holy word"  

The intellect most certainly can lead you to wisdom if your mind is open although it cannot if your mind is closed.

In the Holy Love of God I am your brother in Christ and my name is Royal
Posted 1 year ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

in-{t}elegance - see post above

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 1 year ago #
fishman - Member

royal - i think you and i are mostly in agreement but we are using slightly different meanings for our terms. 

I think you are confusing the faculty called the intellect ( which can be a means to approach God ) with the general quality of being ( intelligent ) , which can be defined as having a strong intellectual capacity.  

 

For instance, by all accounts Stephen hawking and Albert Einstein were/ are very intelligent men.  hawking however is an atheist and Einstein a sudo deist so neither of them can be said to be wise men and their great intelligence failed to lead them to truth.

 

So where as I would agree the intellect can be a great aid too and is a necessary part of ones salvation ( as is the heart ).  My intent in asking the question was to consider the ways that being highly intelligent can interfere with ones journey towards God.

 

For instance a very intelligent person is better and making up justifications for their sins, then a simple person is. 

 

This kind of think is true for any natural gift, because any strength we posses can become a temptation to pride for us.  Any gift given a man can be used for or against God.

 

Ben Franklin put it this way “ a learned blockhead is twice the blockhead of an unlearned one”

Posted 1 year ago #
noelfitz - Member

Royal

You wrote:

Intellect is merely the workings of your brain.

I wonder. Intellect and will used to be considered spiritual faculties.

In harmony, therefore, with Catholic usage, we reserve the terms intellect, intelligence, and intellectual to this higher power and its operations, although many modern psychologists are wont, with much resulting confusion, to extend the application of these terms so as to include sensuous forms of the cognitive process http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/08066a.htm. 

Fishman

You wrote:

 

hawking however is an atheist and Einstein a sudo deist

and 

thanks for the spelling correction.  As it happens the two topics ( poor spelling and intelligence) are actual interrelated.  Most people who have dyslexia also have above 200 IQ's.

Are you trying to prove you IQ is above 200?

Do you have Google or spell checks in the US?

I have only one IQ.

Please look at http://www.hawking.org.uk/home/hindex.html, the official website of Stephen Hawking.

God bless,


NoelFitz.
_________________________________________________
In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas.
“Here I stand. I cannot do otherwise. God help me"

Posted 1 year ago #
fishman - Member

"Are you trying to prove you IQ is above 200?" 

I'm not trying to prove anything , I don't believe very strongly in IQ test ( I won't boar you with mine either ). My poor spelling is in part due to dyslexia.  I run almost everything through a spell checker.  Have you noticed most of my misspellings are correctly spelled words in the wrong context? Spell checkers don't find that unfortunately , nor do grammar checkers necessarily.  Anyway the two are interrelated so I though it an amusing observation given the context. And meant nothing more then that by the statement.

 I miss the point of hawking home page.

Does it say something useful to the discussion? He is well known as both an atheist and a 'genus'.

Adolf Hitler also had a very high IQ, for sake of this discussion he makes just as good and example as hawkings. 

My point is a high IQ is no great advantage to sanctification, and in some circumstance might prove a disadvantage. Weather it is a brain based or soul based functionality is irrelevant to the discussion in that context, because we are discussing the quality of intellgence not it's orgins.

 

 Greater possession of Wisdom, the virtue, however, provides a direct advantage in becoming more holy.

So my initial question might be rephrased in part to read: I am interested in how one can more wisely inform their intellect and avoid the pitfalls associated commonly with academia and intellectual pride.

Posted 1 year ago #
Tarheel - Member

All this is interesting.

 

I would like to say that any intelligence not put to the test of experience is not very useful.  I believe we are truly intelligent if we apply what we have learned through instruction and experience.  Thus we are gaining wisdom.

 

AlvinaL; I really like your comment about prayer.  This is wonderful outline to follow.  Never quite looked at doing my daily prayers in such a manner.

 

fishman; I feel your pain when in comes to spelling.  I don't think I'm dyslexic but my fingers get that way when I type.  Do an Internet search on 'iespell'.  This is a free program that corrects spelling of documents typed and I think it is better that the Google version.  And I never criticize anyone for spelling mistakes.  If you rad this post before I ran a spell check you would be shocked at all the errors.

 

tarheel.

Posted 1 year ago #
lpioch - Moderator

Ok...had to laugh at this one:

So my initial question might be rephrased in part to read: I am interested in how one can more wisely inform their intellect and avoid the pitfalls associated commonly with academia and intellectual pride.

Spoken like a true intellectual!

:-)

*dodging tomatoes*

 

Posted 1 year ago #
pouliot - Member
David T Garrison, re your post:
"inelegance - and ..."
BTW, it was intelegance

How can I tell when you guys are being serious???!!

Regards,
Old Sigma (Cradle Catholic [Latin rite] & generally inveterate amateur)
Posted 1 year ago #
pouliot - Member
Re: LPioch's post:
"Just want to add..."

Nothing could be more natural on a CE forum than to suppose that by "wisdom" is meant sacred wisdom. 

There is besides, believe it or not, human wisdom about the sacred.

Working towards human wisdom about the sacred can help one move to the point where the program LPiosch has sketched is recognized as a reasonable approach in which one ought to invest.

One nugget of human wisdom I have in mind is the dictum of the Greeks:

"Man, know thyself."

Another is:

"Is not is not not is."  (I leave you to punctuate that.)

Another:

When the student is ready, a Master (i.e. a teacher) will appear

These are not just aphorisms and cute sayings.  Reflecting on this sort of folk wisdom, and relating it to the accounts in the Gospels can lead one to realize that human wisdom can gain meaningful insights but will always be limited by the humanity of the practice.  Hence, one realizes where true wisdom lies & what must be the means to attain it.

One must always remember: "The road to Hell is paved with good intentions" and so one must follow-up in a dedicated way, nor in a perfunctory one, in the pursuit.

Some do not require this path.  Some can move directly to the pursuit of the higher wisdom.  But, I think, not all.

Oh, and don't overlook the book of Proverbs.

Regards,
Old Sigma (Cradle Catholic [Latin rite] & generally inveterate amateur)
Posted 1 year ago #
pouliot - Member
Re: Tarheel's post:
"I feel that wisdom and life experiences go hand-in-hand."

Fishman this is an important point & perhaps this coming weekend I can explain how I think this has an important bearing on wisdom seeking.  (But I think that you will be way ahead of me by then.)

Regards,
Old Sigma (Cradle Catholic [Latin rite] & generally inveterate amateur)
Posted 1 year ago #
pouliot - Member
There is a phenomenon, I think it is called "projection," in which one imputes to others the motives that one recognizes in oneself.

Both Sherlock and Perry Mason were into the same sort of thing, but for Holmes it was just a matter of personal conviction.  Mason had to convince the judge.

Does this post strike anyone as a non sequitur?

Regards,
Old Sigma (Cradle Catholic [Latin rite] & generally inveterate amateur)
Posted 1 year ago #
pouliot - Member
Too wise you be. Too wise you are. For the likes of me. (What is the complete quote?)
Regards,
Old Sigma (Cradle Catholic [Latin rite] & generally inveterate amateur)
Posted 1 year ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

pouliot

re: how do I know

I don't know, it takes a while my brother

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 1 year ago #
royal osiodhachain - Inactive
Dear Noel, Here is the defintion I found: Dictionary.com Unabridged (v 1.1) - Cite This Source
in·tel·lect      [in-tl-ekt] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation
–noun
1.the power or faculty of the mind by which one knows or understands, as distinguished from that by which one feels and that by which one wills; the understanding; the faculty of thinking and acquiring knowledge.
2.capacity for thinking and acquiring knowledge, esp. of a high or complex order; mental capacity.
3.a particular mind or intelligence, esp. of a high order.
4.a person possessing a great capacity for thought and knowledge.
5.minds collectively, as of a number of persons or the persons themselves.

[Origin: 1350–1400; ME < L intelléctus, equiv. to intelleg(ere) to understand + -tus suffix of v. action; see intelligent]

—Synonyms 1. reason, sense, common sense, brains. See mind.
In the Holy Love of God I am your brother in Christ and my name is Royal
Posted 1 year ago #
royal osiodhachain - Inactive
Dear Ipioch, I believe this is what you are looking for, John Paul 11 explains the proper use of intellect:

 

ADDRESS OF HIS HOLINESS JOHN PAUL II
TO THE PARTICIPANTS IN A CONFERENCE ORGANIZED BY
THE VATICAN OBSERVATORY SCHOOL IN ASTROPHYSICS

Friday, 28 June 1996

 

Ladies and Gentlemen,

1. I am pleased to greet you on the occasion of this fourth conference in the series devoted to dialogue between philosophy, theology and science. As you continue to consider God's action in the physical world, you turn now to the complex issue of the nature of life itself, seeking to arrive at a fuller understanding of the universe and man's place within it. Your dedication to this undertaking is in line with the Church's long tradition of intellectual commitment, as expressed for example by Saint Augustine: "Intellectum valde ama" (S. Augustini, Epistula 120, 3, 16) truly love the intellect, truly seek after understanding.

2. If scientific endeavour, philosophical inquiry and theological reflection are to bring genuine benefit to the human family, they must always be grounded in truth, the truth which "shines forth in all the works of the Creator and, in a special way, in man, created in the image and likeness of God" (I?annis Pauli PP. II Veritatis Splendor, Introductio). This is the truth which "enlightens man's intellect and shapes his fr??d?m" (Ibid.). When related to this truth, advances in science and technology, splendid testimony of the human capacity for understanding and perseverance, spur men and women on to face the most decisive of struggles, those of the heart and of the moral conscience (Cfr. Ibid. 1).

3. What you do as scientists, philosophers and theologians can contribute significantly to clarifying the vision of the human person as the focus of creation's extraordinary dynamism and the supreme object of divine intervention. Thus there is an intimate link between the development of scientific perspectives on divine action in the universe and the betterment of mankind. Those who work through the sciences, the arts, philosophy and theology in order to advance our understanding of what is true and beautiful are walking a path of discovery and service parallel and complementary to that followed by those who engage in the struggle to improve peoples' lives, fostering their genuine good and development. In the final analysis, the true, the beautiful and the good are essentially one.

4. From this point of view, I consider that this series of Conferences, seeking to relate and unify the knowledge derived from many sources, offers an important contribution to that exchange between religion and science which I have made every effort to promote since the first days of my Pontificate. Grateful for the work you have already done in this field, I pray that you will continue to pursue with professional expertise this important inter-disciplinary dialogue.

Upon you and your work I invoke the blessings of Almighty God.

In the Holy Love of God I am your brother in Christ and my name is Royal
Posted 1 year ago #
noelfitz - Member

I am disappointed with the anti-intellectualism, anti-learning, anti-thought bias of American Catholics.  They seem to pride themselves in their lack of knowledge of their Catholic faith, traditions and history. 

I would like to refer subscribers to a recent article in the September 10, 2007, issue of "America," by Father Wilson D. Miscamble, C.S.C. in which he writes:

Students emerge from Catholic schools rather unfamiliar with the riches of the Catholic intellectual tradition and with their imaginations untouched by a religious sensibility. 

He notes that Notre Dame University does not strive to maintain a predominant number of Catholic intellectuals.

This is understandable if Catholic intellectuals do not exist, which I imagine is the case if the views in this discussion in CE reflect Catholic opinion in the US.

God bless,


NoelFitz.
_________________________________________________
In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas.
“Here I stand. I cannot do otherwise. God help me"

Posted 1 year ago #
royal osiodhachain - Inactive

Dear Noel, I am so happy that you are beginning to see through the deceit of Americans who profess Catholic faith. As I already informed you, America is predominately Protestant and so even the Catholic culture of faith is interspersed with Protestant grains of choking weed. That is why I am so on the alert to anything that evens smells like Protestant mindset. I did not mean to offend your holiness, nor your faith and reason. I am simply gunshy of American religious smart talk.

I have not been to Ireland in my life. My wife went there several years ago and described it as though she were in heaven.

We need your prayers Noel for America to survive as I foresee a terrible fate for this country. Pope John Paul 11 described America as the culture of death and so it is.

We all would benefit from your interjections of truth and the gift of understanding [from the Holy Spirit]

May God bless you, Noel in Jesus Holy Name

In the Holy Love of God I am your brother in Christ and my name is Royal

Posted 1 year ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.

Donate

Welcome to our redesigned site. Your continued support will make further improvements possible. Please click here to donate.

CE Spotlight

Faith Factory

Champions of Faith Ad

Radio & Podcasts


Rock Solid with Mark Shea: April 14, 2008 - Confirmation: Piety and Knowledge