Catholic Exchange Forums » Faith and Life

Another Anti-Catholic Group

(44 posts)
  • Started 11 months ago by Tarheel
  • Latest reply from Tarheel

1 2
Tarheel - Member

This past Sunday when I got to my truck after Mass with my family someone had put a flyer on several cars in the parking lot.  These flyers were from the Tony Alamo Ministries New Jerusalem.  Today out of curiosity I visited their website as the flyer seemed harmless.

http://www.alamoministries.com/

 

After briefly looking at this site a question comes to my mind, "Why is it that so many people choose to hate the Catholic Church?"  Even as a child when I was being taught to hate the Catholic Church (I'm a converted Southern Baptist) I could never fully understand the reasons.  But I was a "good son" and followed along.  But today I still don't understand.  It really makes no sense to me.

 

Beware this site will make you sick.

 

Tarheel

Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

Dave,

Satan hates the Catholic Church...

I am not saying that the Southern Baptist is satanic, but the protestant revolt is most definitely the work of the evil one.

In Christ,

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #
Tarheel - Member

Understand the Satan part.  I won't say all protestants are satanic.  But it still makes me wonder why at times.

Tarheel (Dave)

Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

???

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #
DebR - Inactive

I, too was Southern Baptist.  I wasn't taught to "hate Catholics" but they were certainly suspect.  I think part of it is cultural.  As a non-liturgical church, Southern Baptists find "ritual" to be suspect [not recognizing they have their own, I might add!].  My coming into the Catholic Church was a long, arduous process, partly because I had to rethink a lot of things. 

As I said, part of it is cultural.  The traditions are so different, and, I believe, both are valid.  I am grateful for my heritage, and still have many precious Southern Baptist people in my life who are vital Christians.  I am Catholic, not because the Catholic Church is "better"--though I believe it is.  I am Catholic because it's where God led ME.  I am a witness to my Catholic faith, certainly, but full conversion is God's business.

Most of the misunderstanding stems from the fact that things are so different when you are part of them, as opposed to looking at something from the outside.  You can't convince someone else [very easily] of the value of contemplative prayer or Bible reading.  It's something we come to value experientially.  From the inside.  An onlooker might suppose they're both a waste of time!

Certainly, the enemy is opposed to the Church.  And when God's people wake up and experience true conversion and renewal and begin to impact the culture of death, the enemy comes out full force against them.

 

Posted 11 months ago #
Tarheel - Member

Thanks DebR.  My conversion to the Church was where the Lord led me.  My process too was long.  It was arduous as I was in the military and if I wasn't moving the priest was.  And each time I had to start all over again.  My conversion process took about 6 years and 7 priests.

I still hold close to my heart my friends and family that are still protestant.  I don't try to convert them but I do invite to Mass with us when they visit.  And I agree that it is the rituals that is one thing they fear.  Not sure if it is out of not understanding or being mislead by their respective church leaders.

 

Over the years as I have studied more and more about the Church, I keep coming to the same realization.  What the Church teaches is right.  Once you know the truth you can't help but accept it and believe it.  Maybe that is part of the problem, some people don't want to discover the truth.

Tarheel (Dave)

Posted 11 months ago #
Winslow - Inactive

The Catholic Church is hated by most Protestants because the Church proclaims She is the only true Christian church to the exclusion of all others.  We say the Protestant churches are imperfectly Christian and not true churches and that the Catholic Church is the repository of the Christian faith on this planet.  I can't imagine them embracing that doctrine, so it's only natural they would hate anyone who *seems* to denigrate their very existence.

 Of course the Church merely proclaims the truth and it's interpreted as an insult.  In my experience, deliberately.

 

DebR and Tarheel, you are Catholics because, as you say, God led you to the Church.  However, you first had to be open to the truth and willing to be led.  Most Protestants are not open to the truth, which is on the 2000 year old record.  I pray daily their hearts and minds will clear up and they will really seek the truth instead of averting their eyes to it.

Posted 11 months ago #
DebR - Inactive

I have trouble believing the Catholic Church is hated by most Protestants.  Has it been your experience that you feel judged or rejected by the Protestants you have known? 

I also have trouble believing most Protestants are not open to the truth.  I've seen too much evidence of the gifts and the fruits of the Holy Spirit among Protestants for this to be true.  We have the same Spirit, and the Spirit is Truth. 

 

Posted 11 months ago #
Tarheel - Member

I have had some very bad personal experiences with protestants since I converted.  Many in my own family.

Tarheel (Dave)

Posted 11 months ago #
DebR - Inactive
I'm sorry.  I can say I've had some people ask questions.  It's been more along the lines of dialogue, though. 
Posted 11 months ago #
noelfitz - Member

DebR and Tarheel

Thank you for your wonderful posts.

Is the  Church Unity Octave celebrated widely in the US? This year it will be from 18 to 25 Jan.

Church Unity Octave:

The observance of which was extended by Pope Benedict XV to the Universal Church and enriched with indulgences, 25 February 1916, had its inception in 1908 under Reverend Paul J. Francis, when he was a "Pro-Roman" Anglican of tbe Protestant Episcopal Church in the United States http://www.catholic-forum.com/saints/ncd02035.htm.

God bless,


NoelFitz.
_________________________________________________
In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas.
_________________________________________________

Posted 11 months ago #
Protect the Rock - Moderator

It is quite different to look at Christian unity from the perspective of the Church than from the perspective of protestants.

Protestants who do not have any problems with the Church seem (to me) to not have thought about the situation very deeply.

If one is a Christian and is intellectually honest with oneself, one must be Catholic, or Eastern Orthodox  -- or you have to believe the Church is wrong.  Her claims are too outrageous to ignore.

So I grant the anti-Catholic protestants their integrity at least.  They are wrong, but they are consistent.

Posted 11 months ago #
MREINER16 - Member

It's not just Protestants that can be anti-Catholic. Look at what happened in rome this week. La Spiezza University disinvites the Pope because a very few "professors" say that a speech he made there many tears ago as Cardinal Ratzinger was anti- scientific. So much for the free exchange of ideas at a university. The exchange at this university and most of them in the US is you listen to our liberal catholic bashing dribble and you have no opportunity to reply.It is also interesting that the media covered the snub of the Pope fairly extensively, but yet today other than at Catholic websites, I see no mention of the fact that some 100,000 people came to St. Peter's Square in solidarity with the Holy Father. That, my friends is also indicative of the anti-Catholic bias in our media.

 

Thank God for our Holy Father. I pray that he continue to speak and hope that at least some of us listen.

 

 

Posted 11 months ago #
Protect the Rock - Moderator

Agreed.

My favorite media straight line was a CNN reporter at JP2's funeral events in Rome.  With literally millions of the faithful filling the backdrop, she closed her report with, "The real question is, 'Can the Church be relevant today?'"

My wife laughed and said, "Turn around and open your eyes, silly!"

That is what our world needs to hear:

Turn around and open your eyes, silly!

Posted 11 months ago #
Tarheel - Member

I agree that the media hinges on being anti-catholic but, I would be more prone to describe them as Catholic ignorant. 

 

Do any of you ever get the impression that our wonderful Catholic faith and religion is the most mis-understood?

Tarheel (Dave)

Posted 11 months ago #
MREINER16 - Member

I would like to think that it is just a matter of education, but I feel that at many segments of the media are biased. I truly believe they hear the message of the Church-love, self-sacrifice, right to life, care of neighbor and they reject it. They in turn promote a culture of death, greed, sex, drugs and violence. So, I do believe we need to keep on evangelizing and spreading the Good News, but I also come from the school of "know thine enemy"!

Posted 11 months ago #
yanastrovich - Inactive

Tarheel, The reason the Catholic church is so hated and Catholics also is because Jesus said, "If they hated me they will hate you also". The reason Jesus was hated was partially because the priests of Rome at the time of Christ were envious of [his] power and authority.

I have found a simple way to determine a friend of Christ: A person who adores him/herself is an enemy. A person who adores Christ is a friend.

 In the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit, Amen

Posted 11 months ago #
noelfitz - Member

Y

You wrote:

the priests of Rome at the time of Christ were envious of [his] power and authority.

I am wondering about the priests of Rome at the time of Christ. 

Who were they?

God bless,


NoelFitz.
_________________________________________________
In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas.
_________________________________________________

Posted 11 months ago #
bhokuto - Member
The Church if you look at it from this perspective that it is the "mystical body of Christ" is never wrong.  But, if you look at Church from this perspective, that it's members are still learning what is correct, "men who do not study Gods word"  and not guided by Holy Spirit leads to errors and causes schisms.  But it doesn't necessarily mean they are stagnant, they just are being converted and have some other thing influencing there current conclusion(s). Pray Pray Pray!

Point being, some of the claims the members have made are astoundling insane and not true dogma, doctrine.  Therefore, men when not in union with the Holy Spirit become their own interpreters and have many forms of strange Christianity.

Satan likes to [ puff ] up instead of humbling.  The benevolent Spirit is not puffy.

Peace

Peace
Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

Is any one recognizing a trend with our brother Bobo? He claims to be Catholic, but is continually questioning the authority of the same. Along with a handful of other questionable stances...

In Christ,

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #
Winslow - Inactive

Actually, no, David, I don't see the trend you speak of.  Bobo (or Boko) spoke of members of the Church who do not study Scripture and are not guided by the Holy Spirit.  Couldn't be the Magisterium he's talking about.   Must be the mis-guided laity and clergy who teach and preach heresy.  

He didn't challenge any doctrine or dogma, but took to task those who do.  I, too, find some of the claims of Catholic clergy and laity 'astoundingly insane and not true dogma.'  If you want your accusation to stick, you need to be a little more specific.  There is no questioning of the authority of the Church I can see.  Could you point it out?

 

Peace

Posted 11 months ago #
Winslow - Inactive

DebR, maybe 'hate' is too strong, but I don't doubt there is a strong anti-Catholic bias in all Protestants.

You asked: <<Has it been your experience that you feel judged or rejected by the Protestants you have known?>>>

This isn't going to come off too well, but it's what I believe, so I'm going to say it;  I don't consider Protestants well enough equipped to judge or reject me.  They haven't the intellectual acumen to pull it off.  That's not arrogance, but an acknowledgement of the truth.  As has been allluded to above, if Protestants were open to the truth, they'd be Catholics.  The truth is available to them but most *choose* to ignore it.  That's obstinancy and I have no sympathy for the obstinant.

 

You also said: I also have trouble believing most Protestants are not open to the truth.>>>

 

What, then prevents them from adhering to the truth.  By dint of their faith and their rejection of Catholicism, they reject the truth.  Res ipsa loquitor

 

There is no question most Protestants are sincere in their faith and are good Christians by any definition.  That does not, however, exclude the possibility of bias and/or bigotry against the Catholic Church. 

"One may smile and smile and be a villain."

 

Peace

Posted 11 months ago #
redeemed - Inactive

"Why is it that so many people choose to hate the Catholic Church?"  Even as a child when I was being taught to hate the Catholic Church (I'm a converted Southern Baptist) I could never fully understand the reasons.  But I was a "good son" and followed along.  But today I still don't understand.  It really makes no sense to me."

Sir, If you read the Bible (King James Version) the Word of God will tell you what makes sense. The Word of God will tell you to keep all of God's commandments and Jesus is The Word.

John ch. 1 v.1 :The Word of God, In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God.   Genesis ch.1 verse 26- Let Us make man in our image. 

Catholic doctrine will take your soul to a burning pit of hell for all of eternity. There is NO purgatory. It's either heaven or hell.

Why do I say that? - Because No where in the Bible does it say to pray to Mary - Mary was an incubator - a women chosen to carry the son of God.

Ask yourself - Why would God send His only son to this world to save your soul from hell and then expect you to go to a mom for forgiveness.

That's what doesn't make sense! 

Jesus was beaten beyond recognition, his beard was ripped from his face, he was mocked and spit on. Mary didn't suffer any of that.

Wouldn't you rather go to someone that has - been there - done that - to get comfort for your troubles?  

 think about it

 

Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

redeemed{hopefully},

The fact that you do not understand Mary's place in salvation history{Lk 1:30 KJV} aside, you wrote, " Jesus was beaten beyond recognition, his beard was ripped from his face, he was mocked and spit on. Mary didn't suffer any of that."

According to the Bible, Mary was there, with Him.{Jn 19:25 KJV} Please tell me what mother, in the truest sense of the word as is fitting for the one chosen by God to carry His Eternal Word, does not suffer when her child is harmed in any way, let alone the persecution and death that our Lord endured?

You wrote, "Wouldn't you rather go to someone that has - been there - done that - to get comfort for your troubles?"

Catholics do go to Jesus, Mary as a kind and gracious mother brings us to Him and speaks kindly of us, so that our sinful names might be more pleasing to His ears.

You wrote, "think about it"

The Catholic Church has thought about it. In fact they prayed about it, requested guidance from the Holy Spirit about it, and have proclaimed the truth about it-for two thousand years. After the revolution in the 1500's, Martin Luther wrote about her, Mary, to whom all honor should be given. In trying to break as many ties with the true Church, certain protestant denominations sought ways to discredit the Church so they attacked Her Mother.

How does a Son react when one attacks the mother whom only after she was given to the apostle John, whom He also loved, and he given to her, did He declare that all things were now accomplished? Jn 19:26-28 KJV

Have you?

incubator, indeed!

In Christ,

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me... Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #
Tarheel - Member

Thanks David for a response back to redeemed. 

 I suppose I should get into some dialogue here with redeemed about the comments made.  And perhaps tonight when I get home from work I may do just that.

 

But for now the only response or question I have is this. 

"If you ask someone to pray for you is that wrong?" 

 

"Is it all that different  than me asking Mary the Mother of Jesus to pray for me?"

 

 

 

Tarheel (Dave)

Posted 11 months ago #
MREINER16 - Member
Do we need any more proof of the hate that at least some Protestants (see "redeemed" above) have for Catholics.
Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

Winslow,

You wrote, [Bobo (or Boko)] spoke of members of the Church who do not study Scripture and are not guided by the Holy Spirit.  Couldn't be the Magisterium he's talking about.  Must be the mis-guided laity and clergy who teach and preach heresy.  

I disagree with your interpretation.

Bobo{Boko} wrote this in another thread, " Pretty biased if you ask me.  How many mothers have sacrificed their lives for their families and have gone on unnoticed?  Many, countless.

This is just one example of the biased ways of the Vatican leadership.  

In another, Bobo{Boko} wrote, "Heresy is really a thing that goes against what the Christ teaches.  What Christ teaches?  Yes, the Church only repeats His Words, and if the Church adds to His Words and changes His words, than the Church has stepped into Heresy.  This is an example, because this did happen back in the day.  So, it behooves one to examine and be patient not to condemn something of it's members as St. Paul writes about in Corinthians.  That is to be well rounded.  The Holy Spirit is the one who guides, teaches, counsels, and so forth through those who are Faithful to God." {Here, in my opinion, he is not talking about the Magesterium} -emphasis mine-

and there is more{trend} from other threads over the last few months.

In Christ, 

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

Dave,

That is why I said he/she does not understand Mary, on many levels. He/she has bought into the protestant detestation of Mary, the mother of Jesus. At whose breast, the Saviour of mankind did feed, and of whom God commanded to honor.{Ex 20:12}Possibly, the way our world treats women{and young girls} in general, fuels this perception of who Mary is.

Think about it, if you were God, contemplating a mother for your only begotten Son, the One whom would need to be nurtured and loved as a human baby should be; You who forms all in the womb{Psalm 139:13 KJV}, who would you create for the Redeemer of mankind? How could Jesus, the Great Rabboni{Teacher}, who came to fulfill the Law{Mt 5:17-18 KJV}, disobey the commandment to honour thy father and thy mother? Dt 5:16 KJV

Again, how can a Son, the Son of God, honor His mother by allowing her to be dishonored? If he did, would He not dishonor His Father. {Prov 1:8-9, 6:19-21, 23:22 KJV}

An incubator?

What an insult to our God and our Lord, Jesus Christ. The King of Kings brought into the world simply, lovingly, from the womb{Lk 1:35 KJV} of a humble servant{LK 1:38 KJV} to the bosom of a loving woman, Mary.

redeemed, no longer follow blindly those who have set you on this path. Avail yourself of the great wealth of knowledge available. If you like, a book or two can be recommended...Lk 1:41-55 KJV

In Christ, 

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #
lpioch - Moderator

Redeemed:

Consider yourself fully warned as a last warning.  You have not followed the "Forum Rules", namely:

While we welcome everyone who seeks a better understanding of the Catholic faith, or who would like to dialogue with Catholics about religious differences, we will not tolerate "Catholic-bashing" or gratuitously insulting posts about the Church, its beliefs, its practices, or its persons, including the pope, other Church ministers, and the Blessed Virgin.

This is a first and final warning.

I am leaving up the original post as there have been a few responses to it already. 

That being said, we have to warn you - as a poster on the Catholic Exchange forums - you are being prayed for.  And we hope you will continue to pray for us, too.

Posted 11 months ago #
David T Garrison - Inactive

redeemed,

You wrote, "Wouldn't you rather go to someone that has - been there - done that - to get comfort for your troubles?"  

Ironic, isn't it, that you chose these words with "think about it" as your last. Rather succinctly, you have brought together the Church teaching on Mary in your attempt to provoke the opposite.

Yes, redeemed, who other than Mary, should one turn to if they want to know about the Son and everything He went through for us? Who was there on "the Way"? {Lk 1:35 KJV} Who saw His first breath, gave Him His first drink, satisfied His first hunger and clothed His naked body? {Lk 2:6-7 KJV} Who saw Him take his first step and utter His first word? Who brought Him before the God of all the universe? {Lk 1:22-24 KJV} Who counseled Him in all she knew of God, and with Joseph, carried out to perfection what all parents are called to do? {Dt 6:6-7}

Who brought Him to the feasts? {Lk 1:41-42 KJV} and brought Him through to adulthood? {Lk 1:51-52 KJV} Who was there at His first miracle intervening for a friend? {Jn 2:1-3 KJV} Who was there when He was teaching? {Mt 12:46-50, Jn 2:12 KJV} Who was there at the foot of the Cross? {Jn 19:25} Who was with the Apostles after His death? {Acts 1:14}

Yes, redeemed, who else to go to in times of trouble that can lead us to the Truth, than Mary!

In Christ,

There, now you have a couple of little Abe Lincolns from me...

Remember, the Sun is always shining!

Posted 11 months ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.

Donate

Welcome to our redesigned site. Your continued support will make further improvements possible. Please click here to donate.

CE Spotlight

Faith Factory

Champions of Faith Ad

Radio & Podcasts


Rock Solid with Mark Shea: April 14, 2008 - Confirmation: Piety and Knowledge