Catholic Exchange Forums » Faith and Life

Lock’em up and throw away the key

(21 posts)
  • Started 2 years ago by noelfitz
  • Latest reply from noelfitz

noelfitz - Member
This afternoon I read an article in the Tablet (a magazine similar to America) by Fr Drinan SJ on prisons in the US. His views now are similar to those in 2002 as expressed in http://ncronline.org/NCR_Online/archives/121302/121302q.htm. He claimed that the US has 2.1 million people in prison. In every year 13.5 million people spend some time in American jails. They are a huge industry ($60 per annum). America, the Land of the Free, apparently, has more prisoners than any other country on earth. Are Fr Drinan’s figures correct? Are US Catholics concerned about the numbers locked up? Are Catholics campaigning for prison reform? Do US Catholics see prisons as places of rehabilitation/education, punishment/retribution or ware-housing? Please let me know what you think. God bless, NoelFitz. _________________________________________________ In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas _________________________________________________ PS What does RSS mean in our new web page?
Posted 2 years ago #
RandyGritter - Inactive
I am not sure of the exact numbers but my understanding is the US has a VERY high rate of imprisonment. It is especially high amoung black males. This isn't usually seen as the problem. It should be but the problem is usually described as a crime problem. They are 2 sides of the same coin but one view tends to have sympathy for the people in prison while the other view tends to engender anger towards the same people. As Catholics we believe there are no bad people. There are just good people who commit bad acts. The acts must have consequences but we can never give up on a human being.
Posted 2 years ago #
mkochan - Moderator
There are so many problems with US jails and prisons that it is impossible to go into all of them.  There is a lot of corruption, kickbacks with contracts etc. There is lots of money to be made on everything from contruction to the phone contracts. It is a great sin.  Earlier intervention with disadvantaged youth is definitely needed.
Posted 2 years ago #
wljewell - Member
Our prisons reflect us well, don't they, both in population and problems with the whole issue. I have to admit that we have no choice but incarcerate an awful lot of persons who seem to have no idea how 'good' they are so they can act that way. For most of our two hundred and forty year history, we have experienced greater crime than other lands. But, then, other lands are not as heterogenous - yon melting pot - which can cause great frictions; and especially where plenty proliferates next to want. As to interventions, it has to start with would-be parents, and parents needing help about child development. If we help the parents, we will help the children. A big plus is the numbers of marriages that will not end in divorce for having a strong positive focus on the needs of the family taking position, posture and status over individual impulses. For another, the very changes in parents will cause children to understand how important they are, how important their actions are. If we would empty prisons, we will have to fill families with purpose and grace. Of course, this also presumes filling families with children, eh? I have made similar observations about returning the Church pews to full. If we teach catechism (Bible study, prayer meetings, discussion groups, serious fellowships in missions, etc.) to parents, they will better strengthen their Catholicism, and their children will be raised by devout, actively Catholic parents. I remain your obedient servant, but God's first, Pristinus Sapienter (wljewell @mail.catholicexchange.com or ...yahoo.com) PS: Like me, NoelFitz, I see that you forgot to wear your pancake . . .
Posted 2 years ago #
noelfitz - Member
I am very grateful to Randy, Mary and Pristinus for their replies. Here in Ireland we also have problems. Our treatment of prisoners is not ideal. The re-offending rate seems very high. Most prisoners come from very deprived backgrounds and the amount of addiction to alcohol and heroin is very high among our prison population. In fact the life-expectancy among prisoners and their families is short. However there are a number of individuals and organizations trying to help prisoners. There is a disproportionate number of nuns and priest who try to help prisoners. For the most part there work is unknown and not recognised. In particular Fr Peter McVerry SJ has been a tremendous fighter for the rights of the deprived including prisoners, especially the younger ones. He is especially concerned with homeless young people. You might like to look at: Peter McVerry Award CatholicIreland God bless, NoelFitz. _________________________________________________ In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas _________________________________________________ PS Pictures show halos not pancakes. NF.
Posted 2 years ago #
wljewell - Member
(Some problems with your links, there, but . . .) Like you, noelfitz, Father McVerry sounds like a honey of a saint. His steps are in the right direction, because he is getting the attention of pre-married young persons, whom he can work with to effect to change the dynamics and paradigms from which they come. (Do you feel compelled to try to help this missionary, somehow?) We have prison ministries, too; but, both of our cultures have become so hostile to such 'religious' work, the workers in these ministries, with many lay persons among religious, don't get much attention and support. We will get recidivism (return to prison due to return to crime) where there is little of such help as at Father McVerry's hostels and clinics. Secular 'half-way houses' work somewhat, but, clearly, not enough. Those leaving prison tend to be left to the same influences that put them there to begin with. As with many here at CE, I'd love to meet you. You have such gentle words, and the face of an open, honest, sincere person. (Contrasting to my own avatar portrait; looking like a melon with mold . . .) Thank you for your picture . . . I remain your obedient servant, but God's first, Pristinus Sapienter (wljewell @mail.catholicexchange.com or ...yahoo.com)
Posted 2 years ago #
noelfitz - Member
Hi Pristinus Sorry my links did not work. Are these any better: Peter McVerry Award CatholicIreland Many groups in Ireland try to help prisoners and ex-prisoners, among them the St Vincent de Paul Society, the Samaritans and the Quakers. Your kind words were nice to read, but unfortunately inappropriate. One thing I like about CE is that one can express one’s views and if they are not in conformity with orthodox Catholic teaching one will be gently told. God bless, NoelFitz. _________________________________________________ In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas _________________________________________________
Posted 2 years ago #
mkochan - Moderator
I'd love to have some people who are successfully addressing these issues send articles to us.
Posted 1 year ago #
wljewell - Member
Define 'success' in this venue . . . Rehab of some sort? Hence, too, employment help, once released? Reuniting with families that were not so much cause of criminal conduct? Accepting Christ? Proverbs would warn us that fools tend to stay fools, except as they attend to God's will. However, any resume for a job has no reference to God's wisdom and will. And, the unemployed former fool is likely to fall back into his folly . . . For another thing, with so many convicted and incarcerated persons being black, what are perceived as 'white' religion and principles have little appeal. (Remember, we are still dealing with persons alienated from most society nearly from toddlerhood; hence my choice to attend to development of parenting for long-range difference, here.) The black convicts are more likely to be converted to Islam than, say, even Baptist or other Protestant sect. Islam has its appealing function of 'infidel' to go along with any alienation and/or rage the convict is quite likely to possess. This element of the 'melting pot' holds on to too much heat. I would imagine 'success' varies, and one convict at a time . . . I remain your obedient servant, but God's first, Pristinus Sapienter (wljewell @mail.catholicexchange.com or ...yahoo.com)
Posted 1 year ago #
noelfitz - Member
Thank you for your replies, Mary and PS. I would consider ‘success’ in helping prisoners on release from prison as enabling them to live without drugs , not re-offending and not being homeless. ‘Success’ in helping them in prison might involve helping them to get through each day with the dignity of a human being. I do not think visitors can, or should, directly evangelise in prison. The role of Christian visitors to prisoners is to listen to and support them in a non-judgemental way. Those in the ministry of prison visitation hope to hear the words I was in prison, and you came to Me. (Mt 25:36) not I was in prison, and you tried to evangelise me God bless, NoelFitz. _________________________________________________ In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas _________________________________________________
Posted 1 year ago #
wljewell - Member
Care to give me odds, noelfitz, of any effective 'firm purpose of amendment' that excludes God? As well, the average convict is being 'evangelized' in various ways among his fellows. Some evangelize toward a cynical life of crime nearly like a religion, or New Age nonsense, or Islam, or Bible-belting in very individualized ways. If I visit a prisoner, and admittedly I never have, I have to think that if I brought 'me' I'd necessarily bring Christ. In effect, much of Christ's salvific recommendations for action very truly bring Christ to Christ. I remain your obedient servant, but God's first, Pristinus Sapienter (wljewell @mail.catholicexchange.com or ...yahoo.com)
Posted 1 year ago #
noelfitz - Member
Hi Pristinus You write:
I have to think that if I brought 'me' I'd necessarily bring Christ. In effect, much of Christ's salvific recommendations for action very truly bring Christ to Christ.
Well said. The Cattolic Encyclopedia has:
The doing of works of mercy is not merely a matter of exalted counsel; there is as well a strict precept ...The Divine command is set forth in the most stringent terms by Christ, and the failure to comply with it is visited with the supreme penalty of eternal damnation (Matthew 25:41): "Then he shall say to them also that shall be on his left hand: Depart from me, you cursed, in everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels. For I was hungry, and you gave me not to eat; ...sick and in prison, and you did not visit me",
God bless, NoelFitz. _________________________________________________ In necessariis, unitas; in dubiis, libertas; in omnibus, caritas _________________________________________________
Posted 1 year ago #
wljewell - Member
In ancient prisons, visits were vital since no food was provided, and warm covering might be needed to be brought in for lack of heating; quite a bit different from today's penal institutions. I once counted (though, now only our good Lord knows where, if on paper,yet) some thirty-four instances of Christ's Presence with us; can't hardly go anywhere without the Best-Most Dude. At the parsing of the sheep from the goats, it His very-ness of Himself, and His grace, His way, His life, etc., that He will be looking for. Resemblance with Him will be starkly obvious to all and anyone; as will too close a kinship with Satan. Visiting the sick when one has chronic illnesses (i.e., I am a diabetic with congestive heart failure) is a tricky thing. My last illness, nearly fatal to me, my physician fully believed that I picked up in his waiting room waiting for a flu shot! A large part of my powerful illness was flu itself - the shot too late for my exposure very likely in his waiting room. Anyway, that leaves me with 25% of a heart, for strength; I won't be taking my Christ with me into any prison population. BTW, have you noticed that we have gotten away from capitalizing references to our God? I myself cannot think of any good reason why. How much more powerful is Matthew's warning thusly:
"Then He shall say to them also that shall be on His left hand: Depart from Me, you cursed, in everlasting fire which was prepared for the devil and his angels. For I was hungry, and you gave Me not to eat; ... sick and in prison, and you did not visit Me".
In hospital, in the sagacious mood of one so close to death all about, I am clever enough to treat any person who enters as if visiting me - I get chatty, animated, and let their presence be part of my healing. Most nurses think that I am as perfect a patient as they can get: gently flirtatious, cheerfully loquacious and gratefully appreciative. And, my humor, in main or breech, never sinks . . . I remain your obedient servant, but God's first, Pristinus Sapienter (wljewell @mail.catholicexchange.com or ...yahoo.com)
Posted 1 year ago #
mkochan - Moderator
It is often very hard for families to visit their prisoners in this country as the prisoners are often sent a good distance away.
Posted 1 year ago #
wljewell - Member
And, yet, who will the prisoners be looking to have visit them? Hmmm . . . You bring up an interesting apostolic mission, having to do with buses full of families and helpers and all, once a month . . . It gives the helpers the ears of the prisoners later about such as responsibility and reform, eh? Come, Holy Spirit, fill with Your love and wisdom the hearts and minds of Your faithful; and kindle in us that conflagration of love and that bonfire of wisdom, that we be as sheep afire even among wolves; and all You would have us be, that You would save us. I remain your obedient servant, but God's first, Pristinus Sapienter (wljewell @mail.catholicexchange.com or ...yahoo.com)
Posted 1 year ago #
RandyGritter - Inactive
It is interesting that when we think about prison ministry we think about saving the souls of the prisoners. When Jesus talks about prison ministry he just talks about you saving your own soul. That is pretty scary. The idea that the way we treat prisoners and the way we treat Jesus are one and the same. You wonder why there are any christians who are NOT actively visiting prisoners. We financially support organizations that do all those things. Somehow it isn't the same as phisically going to visit them. The investment of time and emotion so much greater than writing a cheque.
Posted 1 year ago #
Annie 41 - Inactive
I have read your posts with much interest and as one who has visited a prison (once to visit an acquaintance on death row and once as part of a small group to sing Christmas carols and bring a little Christmas cheer to the inmates) and has actually toyed with the idea of getting involved in the prison ministry, I can tell you that it is not for everyone. I do believe we are all called to serve but the who, what, where and how is different for everyone. I think God gives us all certain talents and gifts and the graces (if we allow them to flow) to use these talents and gifts to serve His people. And in serving His people we open the door for God to work more fully in us and through us. Some are called to specific ministries but for many of us God simply uses our everyday, ordinary lives to work His wonders (if we let Him).
Posted 1 year ago #
delmerjohn - Inactive

Sir Noel, You have been to me most hospitable and charitable as a Catholic friend. I recently joined this exchange to find a Catholic friend. I am most interested in conversing with you on a more secure level as I am being harassed by a poster on CE. If you are interested, I would enjoy being your penpal at my email address of delmerjohn@gmail.com. I am not proposing to replace CE as a meeting place to further address question and answer of Catholic teaching, I simply would enjoy a discussion  of faith with you without interruption and distraction from detractors of the faith present on this forum. You Sir are most welcome as I consider you an honest member of the Catholic church.

A royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people set apart.

Posted 1 year ago #
mkochan - Moderator
Delmerjohn, we all know you are Royal. Our technicians have verified  that RoySheehan,  Royal Osiodhachain, Saint Sebastian, and delmerjohn all post from the same computer. Give up the silly charade. Do you really think Jesus wants you to lie?
Posted 1 year ago #
delmerjohn - Inactive
mkochan, Your technicians are lying, I have used 4 computers from various locations to post on this forum.A royal priesthood, a holy nation, a people set apart.
Posted 1 year ago #
mkochan - Moderator

Royal they ddin't say that you didn't use different computers.  All they have to do is varify that all of your names were ever on the same computer at any time.

They have no reason to lie, whereas you have have a history of it.

Do you think Jesus wants you to lie like this?

We are being kind and patient with yoiu and welcoming you back so give it up.  We all knew anyway.

Do you want your Royal name and account back?

Posted 1 year ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply

You must log in to post.

Donate

Welcome to our redesigned site. Your continued support will make further improvements possible. Please click here to donate.

CE Spotlight

Faith Factory

Champions of Faith Ad

Radio & Podcasts


Rock Solid with Mark Shea: April 14, 2008 - Confirmation: Piety and Knowledge