Catholic Exchange Forums » Faith and Life

Should we Christians imitate saints or God?

(49 posts)

1 2
bhokuto - Member

At my parish and on TV Mass the priests always encourage to follow the "saints" who have gone on before us. I found this to be entirely unbiblical. Here's why:

Ephesians 5:1-9

"Here, then: 'Be imitators of God as beloved children.' Oh! Paul does not say to you, 'Imitate this or that saint!' He tells you, 'Imitate God in his perfections'. To imitate God! To make a continuous effort, therefore, to reach perfection. And to do so with charity, but also with humility; with faith, but also with humility; with hope, but also with humility.

"All of you know that notwithstanding every heroic effort You will always be incapable of possessing the Perfection of God. But do not get discouraged! The Most Holy Father knows, because He is perfect, that the creature cannot be like the Creator, and to comfort you, to justify your relative measure, proclaiming it with justice to be 'perfect for the creature,' He has set a limit for this measure: yours. He has said, 'with your whole selves.' 'With all your heart, with all your soul, with all
your strength,' states the immutable command until the end of the ages; and heretical and accursed is one who changes or alters it or replaces it with a human command for other forms of worship of ideas which are not of God, but are a mixture of hellish smoke and nellish venom with the smoke and venom of a wicked creature.

"When one loves with all one's heart, soul, and strength, one has, for oneself, loved perfectly. One has, therefore, imitated God, who is perfect in Good.

"Paul's second precept: 'Live in love as Christ has loved us and has given Himself to God for us in a holocaust as asweetsmelling host.'

"Perfect love! The love of Jesus Christ, Son of God and Our Lord. Love which arrives at sacrifice. Love for one's neighbor which arrives at immolating oneself for one's neighbor. Love for God to the point of becoming the Immolated One on the altar of Reparation.

"Another precept: 'May they not only not be in you, but not even be mentioned among you'-among you, who must recall only the gifts, perfections, and teachings of God. Fornications, impurity of any kind, avarice.'

You are no longer men. You are 'voices.' John the Baptist "A voice in the wilderness" John the baptist stayed his ground never raised a fist, always out of love(shouting for deaf ears to hear) reproached the "sins" of man for love of man. The Voice of God Himself. For what is love if it does not correct? If it does not bend over and help a poor distressed soul?
Or if it sits in a corner? It is dead. Nevertheless we sacrifice for others as Christ sacrificed for us "the Victim". We exort, we teach, we reproach kindly but we never picket in front of the White House or other government facilities. We pray to the ALmighty Who is the Strongest.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
lpioch - Moderator

The aspect of the saints that we should imitate are the aspects where they imitate Christ. We are all part of the family. We are all part of the Body. It in no way diminishes Christ to imitate his beloved. It shows his strength and gives us great hope.

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

we learn from them what they learned. but we never Follow Man. Because Man Sins. He is a sinner from Birth.

Posted 1 month ago #
MREINER16 - Member

Not having the benefit of the full context of what your priest said, I would say that of course it makes sense to imitate and follow the example of the saints who have gone before us. This does not mean that we replace following God and imitating His Son as our primary example. The saints are by the very nature of their canonization declared by the Holy Church to have led virtuous, heroic and holy lives and She recognzies that because of this and of course the grace of God, they are now in His presence forever. I think your priest may be encouraging the imitation of saints because they were real people some of whom led very terrible and awful lives before their convesrions (St. Paul). Others are from our modern era and are current examples of leading avirtous life in these difficult time. (Maximillian Kobe, Padre Pio, Sister Faustina). When we follow the example of a saint, we are not following that individual; we are in reality following the example they gave the world in following God and Christ.

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Mreiner well said,

yet the highest calling is to Follow Me - Jesus. To Imitate the Master.
Are we in need of a master? Anyone who does not think they need one is indeed not a child. God calls us His children, a child needs always a Master. Master and his disciples. I truly understood what the priests and such are saying here in the U.S.A, because they them very selves are at a loss of what to preach in these harycary times.

I say Follow Jesus and Imitate everything of His Good Will. What He did except for putting the Pharisees' in their place, this is Gods job. We are to only be His disciples and bring the Good News to those poor lost souls.

God calls us to become angels why?

9 Choirs of angels or positions; we are to join one of these choirs in the Hereafter. Did you merit the position of a Seraph? or Cherub? or the lowest of angels? Nevertheless he who is greatest must become like a child.

There is great danger in following a saints example because he/she was declared a saint after the fact. God is constant He does not change.

The Eternal Spirit of God inspires us we are to Listen to the Voice of the Eternal Spirit of God, for he who does not have the Holy Spirit does not belong to God, therefore we pray for them to become light come to the Light.

Why do we not follow and imitate a saint? Because they are not God.
Because your angel tells you to follow Christ.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
MREINER16 - Member

bhokuto- I agree that we should imitate and follow Christ as our prime example, but I must say that I do not see the danger in following and imitating the life of a holy saint. Of course, we all our modeling ourselves on Jesus and this is exactly what the saints did.

I'm not sure what you mean that God calls us to be angels. An angel is a pure spirit created by God and because of their purity they could be with God in Heaven and be His messengers. Now if you mean that we are to be like angels and be Go'd messengers, then I agree. But, if you mean that we are to become angels, then I say no. God created us as human beings, body and spirit. "Let us make man in our image. after our likeness ... So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him: male and female created he them." (Genesis 1:26-27) God created man a bit lower than the angels. "What is man, that thou art mindful of him? ... For thou hast made him a little lower than the angels, and hast crowned him with glory and honour." (Psalm 8:4,5) The New Testament quotes this passage, and tells us that mankind - including the Lord Jesus himself - was made a little lower than the angels, "for the suffering of death" (Hebrews 2:9). Angels do not die, but men and women do. Even Jesus, the Son of God, was a mortal man, but has now received the glory and honour which was his due when, as he said after his resurrection, "all power is given unto me in heaven and in earth" (Matthew 28:18). So in this sense when we imitate and follow Jesus, we are following both his divinity and humanity.

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Mreiner,

As far as angels: When God created all His creatures, He created them Free. Another words with His likeness that is Free. God is Love, love is Free from what binds it. It cannot be overcome unless you freely choose not to be free by succumbing to sin which is slavery. WHic is what Adam and Evd did. THey chose to become slaves to sin by sinning they disobeyed Gods directive of do not Follow Lucifer.

God created man "naked" in Paradise on Earth. Genesis 1 - 3.
When God put earthly clothes on man he clothed there sinfulness.
Angels are clothed with white robes. Revelations
All the saints are clothed in white robes. Revelations.

God is order. God has a hierarchy in Heaven.

Jesus even says to be the greatest; so He tells us right here there is a hierarchy and order for which man can merit a position in Heaven.

We found out through the some of the past Believers that there are 9 choirs of Angels or Hierarchy of Angels. As we gain more merit we gain one of these positions and their attributes. We can gain the highest merit
and obtain the rank of Seraph.

Jesus also shows us in the Gospels about the Roman Centurion who was under rule or authority, how he had more faith than any one in Israel! What a shock! Obedience is what this says. Obedience to Gods Divine Laws.

What is the US ARMY ranking system? Anyone who was in the service can give credence to the Ranking system.

For those who have ears to hear.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Mreiner,

Our Blessed Mother, The Virgin Mary, Mother of God is the Queen of the Celestial Court. She is Queen of the Angels, She is higher than a Seraph.
Because She is the Mother of God.

Jesus is Angel of angels because He is King of Heaven as God the Father decreed. Jesus and Mary, King and Queen of the Celestial Court.

God created Angels as the Mark to Hit for all creatures below Heaven namely Man. To become rulers with Christ, priests who give obeisence to God. What do priest do on Earth? They adore Christ at least that's the design. Pay tribute, give Jesus - Body Blood Soul and Divinity - Holy Eucharist.

Angels receive flashes from God when they have been given a commandment to obey and they obey promptly. I attest to this when God calls I get a flash of light. Talk to your Angel the Guardian of your soul.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Not withstanding, we have what God calls the Communion of Saints.
Who also follow God who help us on our way as Heavenly bodies to imitate
God. Because God gave His breath to us. Genesis 1 and God breathed into his nostrils (into mud) to become a living soul. What is a soul? It is a spirit. What comes directly from God is always spirit. God created the body from mud. Never get these two screwed up.

Man was created to imitate the Creator. This is what Angels do all day long they imitate God.

Why were Adam and Eve created "naked"? to obtain a white robe after a good life in God. The Reward for being good is a white robe, and to be in His presence Eternally. This sounds cheap but there's much more than that.
Your soul/spirit becomes incredibly active in love and is overwhelmed by love continous along with light, Wisdom, beauty, true Beauty. To experience Heaven means to live there. So we are not there yet.

What will we be doing there? Ever escalating in pure esctacy unlike any thing on Earth. THe soul has no limits in doing good and ever climbing the steps to becoming a giant size light. For the limitations of man on earth do not exist there.

Lets say that you enter heaven in the lowest eschalons of angel, you work your way to Seraph, you have all eternity to do so!! Praise the Lord!
You are free as in really free without the slavery of sin to be only limited by the measure God gives. Which is we can never be so proud as to saying "I will be like the Most High and take His throne". Book of Isaiah

Alleluia!

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
noelfitz - Member

Hi Bhokuto

It is good to hear from you. I see you have 5 messages here.

Unfortunately I always seem to disagree with you. I hope it is in the friendly spirit of two people within the Catholic Church, who are trying to keep the faith.

Your very first line is:

"Not withstanding, we have what God calls the Communion of Saints.
Who also follow God who help us on our way as Heavenly bodies to imitate
God."

1. We, the faithful on earth, are part of the Communion of Saints.

2. We do not have Heavenly bodies.

God bless,

NoelFitz.
___________________________________
“When a Catholic does not share a candidate’s stand in favor of abortion and/or euthanasia but votes for that candidate for other reasons, it is considered remote material cooperation, which can be permitted in the presence of proportionate reasons” Cardinal Ratzinger/Pope Benedict XVI.
____________________________________

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

I would like to further your knowledge:

what is a Heavenly Body? it transcends time and space, Your Spirit is a Heavenly Body, because your spirit is the Breath of God created By God, not your Flesh which is created by God from "mud".

Secondly, the Communion of Saints are Saints who have achieved Sainthood.
The Church of Christ is Mystical. His Body which is Mystical.

The Church Militant
The Church paying for their sins(Purgatory)
The Church Glorified: they who made it to Heaven after the first two.

The Church Militant those who are still in the juvenile stage
The Church Purging those who are having their juvenile removed because they failed to have it removed while in the Militant stage.
The Church Glorified those who are adults in Spirits who Love God and Nothing Else.

Does the Pope declare a saint before they pass on? No. It is always after they have examined ones life after death.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

St. Paul was caught up to the third heaven. [New Testament] Was he caught in body and soul or just soul/spirit? His spirit. his body is slag, weight which keeps one bound to the gravity of the Earth. In Spirit he was caught up to the third Heaven or where God and Angels are.

The Vision of St. John the Beloved was given to him by an Angel; book of Revelations or Apocalypse. Angels come to man to give a message, for they are ministering spirits and messengers of God. They have incredible intelligence, superhuman intelligence.

And where does it ever say that we who are militant are saints?
We are to be saints, saints in the making. We belong to the Communion of Saints so long as we practice the Divine Laws of God.

He who is being purified from sin concupiscence is saved already.
Otherwise you would not be on your way to purification if you were not a Chosen of God.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

FYI for those who have been wondering and have heard bits and pieces about Purgatory, there have been many who bring word of Purgatory a little bit here and little bit there compling the full picture.

"I have come to clarify the revelation that the Flame of our Mother's Heart, which is Holy Love, can be likened to the flames of Purgatory. In Purgatory the soul sees clearly all that he has done in thought, word and deed which stood between his soul and the Divine Will. He sees what remains to be atoned for and he willingly casts himself into the purifying flames to be purified."

"When, in the world, the soul chooses to live in Holy Love, he is similarly convicted of any obstacle within his heart which stands in the way. He, with great effort of his free will, tries to purify himself of these iniquities and God sends trials which test and assist him in these efforts. So, in many ways, to immerse yourself in the Flame of Holy Love is a taste of the purifying flames of Purgatory. Let me add that there is no other path if the soul desires holiness."

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

The above is from St. Terese of the Child Jesus.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Maybe you understand what it Means to imitate God? To hear Him through others as well. The saints of yester year who have gone on before
us are enjoying a blissful time in Heaven, but they are along side of us all the way. They repeat Gods Word. We are created by the Word of God, which is from a Thought of God, which is then given a Breath of God.

Those who walk in the Spirit, speak Gods words.

Know ye not ye are the temple of God? The Temple of the Holy Spirit(God the Third Person)
I will not leave you comfortless, but I will send another to comfort you. (the Holy Spirit)

God walks among men because Grace has been restored. Without Grace there can be no salvific work. It will all revert to the time of Abraham where there were very few "minute" I would add "Justified by God" men. Thus
we would end up in being washed by the Great Flood of Noah's Time. Wherein only a few souls were saved by His Grace. These few believed in God even when there were no "10 commandments."

Thus we live in a time where all is harycary. Full of sensuality, pride, greed, all equal the enjoyment of the flesh. None of these care about their souls nor about there plight. Do not be washed alongside them when the flood of God unseen comes. Read Daniel.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
noelfitz - Member

B

As you know I disagree with almost everything you write:

You Wrote:

“Secondly, the Communion of Saints are (sic) Saints who have achieved Sainthood.”

I disagree. The Catholic Encyclopedia defines the Communion of Saints as:

"The communion of saints is the spiritual solidarity which binds together the faithful on earth, the souls in purgatory, and the saints in heaven in the organic unity of the same mystical body under Christ its head, and in a constant interchange of supernatural offices."

I really think it is a waste of time to debate with you, as you ignore posts other than your own.

God bless,

NoelFitz.
___________________________________
“When a Catholic does not share a candidate’s stand in favor of abortion and/or euthanasia but votes for that candidate for other reasons, it is considered remote material cooperation, which can be permitted in the presence of proportionate reasons” Cardinal Ratzinger/Pope Benedict XVI.
____________________________________

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Noel

You speak from Encylopedias. I speak from Above, that's the difference.

TO KNOW.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Noel,

What is Wisdom?

Jesus IS.

What is the Eucharist?

Jesus IS.

Where do these two come from?

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
noelfitz - Member

This is one of the few posts you sent that I agree with (partially).

I have said before and repeat, you may have gnostic tendencies.

Posted 1 month ago #
fishman - Member

The reason why Christians should imitates saints is because the saints imitate God.
Our call is to be like Jesus Christ.
In the gospel of John jesus says this: Now I give you a new command. Love one another as I have loved you.

It is the only time Jesus says 'this is a new command'. We are to love one another as Jesus loved us. The saints that are canonized because their lives are like testimony. Like living books about how to carry out Christ command. We should imitate the saints in the way they imitate Jesus.

As to Jesus being an angel -- you need to re-look up what the word means.
God is pure spirit, but angels are created spirit ( massive difference).

God is more superior to the angels then man is a worm. So to say Jesus is an angle is kind of like saying jesus is worm. The only way God could ever be an angle would be if he became one, in someway we could not understand. The bible says nothing about that though, only that he became a man.

Paul was taken up body and soul. human beings are and always will be body and soul
and to believe otherwise is to deny the last line of the creed. "we believe in the resurrection of the body". When we enter heaven or hell in the final judgement it will be body and soul.

Jesus said to thomas after his resurrection:"Look at my hands. see the wounds, feel my side". Was jesus telling a lie ? Was he deceiving Thomas? If after the resurrection, the part of him that had nails placed in human hands was somehow gone. Then he was deceiving and lying. Our resurrection and our heaven will be the same. To claim otherwise is to believe in heresy.

Also, you are wrong. Neither wisdom or Eucharist come from peace. They come from love.

Where in the bible does it say God is peace?
It does however say God is Love.

And it also say only three things will endure, faith , hope and love and the greatest of these is Love.

Peace is wonderful, but peace is a fruit of being in love with and being loved by the all powerful creator, protector, God.

Posted 1 month ago #
noelfitz - Member

Fishman,

Your recent post was great.

It shows a deep understanding of our faith and is encouraging.

I am reading the Letters of Ignatius at present. He fought the heresy that said Jesus was an angel, that he appeared to be man - docetism.

Posted 1 month ago #
wljewell - Member

bhokuto,

You quote "from St. Terese of the Child Jesus"

One of her greatest goals was emulation of Saint Theresa of Avila. She answers your huffing and puffing for you. The saints are human models of trying to be like the God-Man in life. We canonize them with that highest exemplary aspect fully in mind.

I have found that when I am spoken to, it is a right comradely 'right here next to' me. Murmurs into my heart and mind come to me in prayer as if He talks into my ear of my inmost being - not 'from above' as much as 'from love'.

BTW, of reading, I requested 'Render to Caesar' by Archbishop of Denver, the very Reverend Charles J. Chaput, O.F.M. Cap. from my library. I read it, and immediately ordered it for my personal library. What a great understanding of humankind, Church and God this ordinary delivers. The man's simple, straightforward prose even lifts the heart and spirit. Get it and read it.

Posted 1 month ago #
michaelme - Member

Bhokuto:

You said:

"At my parish and on TV Mass the priests always encourage to follow the "saints" who have gone on before us. I found this to be entirely unbiblical."

I'm sorry to say that you are wrong on two counts. The first is the simplistic belief that the Catholic Church is a Church of the Bible...it is not. We are a Church of the Word in its entirety, meaning both the Bible and the Church's Tradition as set forth, with the guidance of the Holy Spirit, by the magisterium.

See CCC 828:

"By canonizing some of the faithful, i.e., by solemnly proclaiming that they practiced heroic virtue and lived in fidelity to God's grace, the Church recognizes the power of the Spirit of holiness within her and sustains the hope of believers by proposing the saints to them as models and intercessors..."

And secondly, the Bible itself is clear about imitation in 1 Cor. 11:1 "Be imitators of me, just as I also am of Christ.". So the imitation of saints is not only proper from the Church's perspective but the Bible's as well. By the way...the verse immediately following teaches us to attend to those Traditions laid down by the Church and delivered by Paul.

You would do well to heed your own advice and "further your knowledge."

In Christ,
Michael

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

This what St. Paul says:

Galatians 5:18-25

Brothers and sisters:
If you are guided by the Spirit, you are not under the law.
Now the works of the flesh are obvious:
immorality, impurity, licentiousness, idolatry,
sorcery, hatreds, rivalry, jealousy,
outbursts of fury, acts of selfishness,
dissensions, factions, occasions of envy,
drinking bouts, orgies, and the like.
I warn you, as I warned you before,
that those who do such things will not inherit the Kingdom of God.
In contrast, the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace,
patience, kindness, generosity,
faithfulness, gentleness, self-control.
Against such there is no law.
Now those who belong to Christ Jesus have crucified their flesh
with its passions and desires.
If we live in the Spirit, let us also follow the Spirit.

You are all wrong.

First a saint is declared a saint after they have "Passed" on. How did they get there? they followed the Spirit Who Is God and Teaches what Jesus
always Teaches. Love God and Your Neighbor, when You love you imitate God.

Buffoonary at the Highest level is when Man thinks he can follow a Saint who is "Not" God. Jesus says "Clearly" in the Gospels: "Follow Me"

You missed what I said: Saints Speak the Words of God through them God speaks, because they have become Altars for God. That is your Goal to become an Altar for God.

Example: the Tabernacle houses The "Host" Eucharist. A Golden veil which keeps your physical eyes from Seeing inside which Only a Consecrated
Ordained Priest can remove from within to "Give" To You and Myself.

God wants to Inhabit Your Soul just like the Tabernacle so you become Living Tabernacles of God. Heaven is just exactly the same, All the Choirs of Saints and Angels have God inhabiting their Souls.

Imitate God by Loving Him and your Neigbor.

What does God do all day long? 24hours a day? He love us with all His Being.

If you haven't figured this out yet look at the Stars, the Sun, The Moon, the Earth and how He poplulated it with Other Humans and with all the glory of His Name imprinted on each and everyone
of His Creations. The whole Universe pronounces His Glorious Name.

When man takes what God has given over time, man forgets what the first man was given and taught because man is dull-witted due to Original Sin. He sins. Sin makes us dull and stupid thus distortions come in, and every now and then a soul shines in Gods face and he/she becomes a saint
after death when the "Church" declares it. Until then, they are "Not" declared "Saints"

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Another Example:

So if you follow a man who is not yet a saint but in the future becomes one who just like you and myself, are struggling to find there way to Heaven by keeping the commandments of God, who we sometimes have venial and mortal sins, you follow a "creature" not the Creator. Thus you have become "Idolators". What is the crux of the Old Testament? If you follow sin and Satan, Satan because he is the Beastmaster, and sin because it cuts you off from Grace, and in man is resides "Sin" no matter how good you maybe, any man can fall and resume as a sinner at any given time in his or her life.

If you see man yell at his neighbor do you imitate that? Even he/she was declared a saint? No, God say "Love". You really haven't thougt deeply enough about Purity, Charity, Chastity so that is why You say I can Imitate a Saint. They struggled.

God is perfect, We must imitate Perfection because that's what it takes to enter Heaven.

Thus,

"When one loves with all one's heart, soul, and strength, one has, for oneself, loved perfectly. One has, therefore, imitated God, who is perfect in Good.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

When the Spirit of God descends into your Altar because in the Temple is an Altar, No ye not you are the Temples of the Holy Spirit? WHO is God?

Your souls become Gods Altar and it is Wisdom Who Guides and when you Connect the Dots, of which most of you have not, it is then God Who inhabits your temples and thus you become a saint so long as you maintain this lifestyle in "Love".

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Fishman,

You famous qoutes "Be Perfect as God is Perfect" what is being perfect according to God? The Commamdment From God which helps us become perfect.

Love God above all else with all your being and love your neighbor as yourself, for Love is the Perfection of the Law.

Thus a weak man who we all are, because of Sin, we listen to the Spirit of God Who guides us all.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Without the Holy Spirit, "there can be no saints." Thus they listened to the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit may have you see some quality of God in another, that is that they were able to comprehend what I just said above, Become Altars for God, that is what Saints have done and thus finish the race at the pearly Gates after they crawled, dashed, ran up the mountain of God to reach God.

If you follow Jesus the Messaiah who is man, you become Idolators, If You follow Jesus the Son of God, you become acquainted with God the Father.
Jesus is both God and Man, He came as man to accomplish the deeds which no other man could accomplish that is He was "without" Sin. The Perfect Sacrifice for Man. A Redeemer has to be without Sin.

Think on this for awhile and then if you still say you can imitate a Saint, well God bless.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Wjew,

I read what the Holy Spirit tells me to read.

So far there are only 5 good books that come from the "Correct" source. All the rest repeat mans ideas.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #
bhokuto - Member

Once You read the Bible with the Right attitude and with Love, you know the Master's Voice and want Only That. The rest is foobar.

Peace

Posted 1 month ago #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.

Donate

Welcome to our redesigned site. Your continued support will make further improvements possible. Please click here to donate.

CE Spotlight

Faith Factory

Champions of Faith Ad

Radio & Podcasts


Rock Solid with Mark Shea: April 14, 2008 - Confirmation: Piety and Knowledge